Dr Ezekiel Emanuel, a former Obama Administration official, said he plans to swear off all medical treatment after age 75 so he can die while he is still healthy and vibrant The doctor, who is. Opposition to legalization of euthanasia (1997), Rationing, death panel controversy (2009), "The Perfect Storm of Overutilization" (2008). cannot be separated from other values, like saving the most lives. Active, vigorous, engaged, animated, astute, enthusiastic, funny, warm, loving. Zeke, as he is known, is influential in many ways, but his work that starts the most arguments is an essay entitled Why I want to die at 75. Emanuel made a related comment during an interview for The Washington Post, when he said that improving the quality and efficiency of healthcare to avoid unnecessary and even harmful care would be a way to avoid the need for rationing. In October 2014, Ezekiel Emanuel published an essay in the Atlantic called " Why I Hope to Die at 75. Emanuel said that claims of cost saving from assisted suicide are a distortion, and that such [69][70], In the 2008 Journal of the American Medical Association article "The Perfect Storm of Overutilization"[71] Emanuel said, "Overall, US health care expenditures are 2.4 times the average of those of all developed countries ($2759 per person),[clarification needed] yet health outcomes for US patients, whether measured by life expectancy, disease-specific mortality rates, or other variables, are unimpressive." It is not just mental slowing. He said that legalized euthanasia in the Netherlands did not adhere to all the legal guidelines, and that some newborns were euthanised even though they could not possibly have given the legally required consent. It also provides strong financial incentives to preserve such inefficiency. Part of the Daily Mail, The Mail on Sunday & Metro Media Group, REVEALED: Paul Pelosi 'attacker' was 'trying to MURDER 82-year-old' and likened himself to the Founding Fathers in interview with cops: Speaker's husband scrambled to bathroom to call 911 after being stopped from using phone in home's elevator, Elon Musk confirms he'll be new Twitter CEO as his team reveals its plans to immediately drop 25 PERCENT of the company's 7,000-strong workforce: Layoffs will hit nearly every department, Democrats demand a national security investigation into Saudi Arabia's stake in Twitter under Elon Musk: Senator says Kingdom wants to repress political speech and impact US politics, Republicans are 'privately bracing for Trump to be INDICTED 60 to 90 days after the midterm elections' - and think a prosecution could HELP him gain more support, Dow Jones records its best monthly rise in nearly 50 YEARS as stocks surge 14% despite slipping on Halloween and slowing tech sector growth, Baby girl, 1, and her 12-year-old sister are among five people killed in horror head-on crash in Florida, REVEALED: Tom Brady was 'trying to fix' marriage with Gisele Bundchen prior to their shock divorce - and the supermodel is 'doing fine' now, Australian porn star Hayley Vernon calls out cringe-worthy American term that has infiltrated her country's vernacular: 'Why do you call it that? It is true, people can continue to be productive past 75to write and publish, to draw, carve, and sculpt, to compose. [25] Emanuel said that for the vast majority of dying patients, "legalizing euthanasia or physician-assisted suicide would be of no benefit. The controversy surrounding Emanuel is due to claims by Betsy McCaughey and Sarah Palin accusing Emanuel of supporting euthanasia. Once the prototype of a hyperactive Emanuel, suddenly his walking, his talking, his humor got slower. You listen to these people and their lingo is not Were just trying to get rid of problems. Right? And a loss it will be. However, the Hippocratic Oath is proof that medical technology is not the cause of medical questions about ethics. There may be a cognitive downside, maybe a little more mental confusion. All of those mental puzzles are an effort to slow the erosion of the neural connections we have. Still, Andrew's lover said that he had talked about such situations, and asked that Andrew be allowed to die. Once I have lived to 75, my approach to my health care will completely change. Is the Government Going to Euthanize your Grandmother? Emanuel was born into a combative clan. Middle brother Rahm is the mayor of Chicago, erstwhile White House chief of staff, and one of the most colorful figures in American politics. [60] According to The Atlantic, Emanuel is describing the philosophy of John Rawls in arguing that society is choosing one value (equality) over another (a healthy society), and this substitution may be responsible for limited choices in health care. "[18], Emanuel and Fuchs reject a single-payer system, because it goes against American values of individualism. ", Essential Elements of a Technology and Outcomes Assessment Initiative, 5 Myths About Our Ailing Health-Care System, Conflict of Interest in Industry-sponsored Drug Development, "Conflicts of Interest for Patient-Advocacy Organizations", "Ezekiel Emanuel Awarded $1M Dan David Prize", "Come for Dinner, Stay for Life: Zeke Emanuel", "Some Scientists Say New Ethics Rules May Damage NIH", Dr. Ezekiel Emanuel explains why he thinks corporations should support Universal Health Care Vouchers, The Health Reform We Need & Are Not Getting, https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Ezekiel_Emanuel&oldid=1135346573, American people of Moldovan-Jewish descent, Members of the National Academy of Medicine, Articles with dead external links from January 2017, Articles with permanently dead external links, Articles with dead external links from December 2016, Short description is different from Wikidata, Wikipedia articles needing clarification from July 2020, Articles with unsourced statements from October 2015, Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License 3.0, This page was last edited on 24 January 2023, at 03:07. Obviously, a do-not-resuscitate order and a complete advance directive indicating no ventilators, dialysis, surgery, antibiotics, or any other medicationnothing except palliative care even if I am conscious but not mentally competenthave been written and recorded. We are programmed to struggle to survive. Does that sound very desirable? Jim Rutennberg said that Emanuel's critics oversimplified complex issues, such as who should get a kidney. Since President-elect Joe Biden tapped Dr. Ezekiel Emanuel, an . Zeke is an oncologist with a master's from Oxford, an MD from Harvard, a PhD in political philosophy from Harvard, and a 27-page CV that includes fellowships, professorships, books, and numerous awards and honors. Similarly, poets tend to peak earlier than novelists do. But there is no getting around the data. He cites the case of a prominent health economist who recently celebrated his 90th birthday and continues to be 'brilliant', but insists that the man is simply 'an outliera very rare individual. Numerous recent trials of drugs that were supposed to stall Alzheimersmuch less reverse or prevent ithave failed so miserably that researchers are rethinking the whole disease paradigm that informed much of the research over the past few decades. It is difficult, if not impossible, to generate new, creative thoughts, because we dont develop a new set of neural connections that can supersede the existing network. Emanuel has opposed euthanasia. A big challenge is antibiotics for pneumonia or skin and urinary infections. Emanuel said that while it is difficult to know when conflicts of interest exist, the fact that they do is "the truth". Do not sell or share my personal information. A: No, notheyre fascinated by their life extension! reach out to us at [37] PolitiFact says that Emanuel was describing the fact that doctors often have to make difficult choices, such as who should get a liver transplant. [38] He had in fact had a heart attack, which led to a cardiac catheterization and ultimately a bypass. Emanuel's brothers are Hollywood agent Ari Emanuel (seen left with his wife) andChicago Mayor Rahm (right). Rather than saving more young people, we are stretching out old age. [21] Ezekiel, and his former wife Linda Emanuel, an M.D. Dr. Ezekiel Emanuel, a leading US oncologist and bioethicist, discusses why he will stop preventative screenings and other major medical treatments after he is 75-years-old. Not quite. Ezekiel Emanuel, Daughters, "Seventy-five, Ezekiel Emanuel, in Chicago, Ezekiel "Zeke" Emanuel is an American oncologist . Emanuel's youngest brother is the president's first chief of staff, current Chicago Mayor Rahm Emanuel. Although well-known in medical and. And once youve got cultural leaders, or opinion leaders, saying this, people glom onto it. The three brothers were raised in Chicago by their fatherIsraeli-born pediatrician Benjamin and motherMarsha, a nurse who was a descendant of Russian immigrants. For example, men are more likely experience severe effects of Covid-19. They might condemn me as being against the elderly. Im not committing suicide. You can't. Dr. Zeke Emanuel, an advisory board member appointed to Joe Biden's coronavirus task force, has argued that rather than vaccinate old people and the people with higher risk first, the priority should be inoculating younger, more productive citizens of the state. After all, evolution has inculcated in us a drive to live as long as possible. Know his, Estimated Net Worth, Age, Biography Wikipedia Wiki. The specificity of 75 means we can no longer just continue to ignore them and maintain our easy, socially acceptable agnosticism. The answer to these symptoms is not ending a life but getting help. We also avoid constantly thinking about the purpose of our lives and the mark we will leave. His argument: older Americans live too long in a diminished state, raising the question of, as he put it, whether our consumption is worth our contribution.. Once you squeeze the creativity out of the neural networks established over your initial career, they are not likely to develop strong new brain connections to generate innovative ideasexcept maybe in those Old Thinkers like my outlier colleague, who happen to be in the minority endowed with superior plasticity. By 1930, it was 59.7; by 1960, 69.7; by 1990, 75.4. Ezekiel Emanuel: Tom, that is a really good question, and I have to say I'm scratching my head, especially if you think the first problem is that, say, the Pfizer vaccine is the first out of the . [4] Emanuel's mother, Marsha, a nurse and psychiatric social worker who was raised in the North Lawndale community on Chicago's West Side, was active in civil rights, including the Congress of Racial Equality (CORE). How can this be? Emanuel vowed to refuse not only heroic medical interventions once he turned 75, but also antibiotics and vaccinations. [50] Republican Senator Johnny Isakson, who co-sponsored a 2007 end-of-life counseling provision, called the euthanasia claim "nuts". After I die, my survivors can have their own memorial service if they wantthat is not my business. Ezekiel Emanuel and Ron Ryden, December 10, 2008. The result would be a two-tiered system, where those with more money could afford more discretionary services. About a decade ago, I began working with a prominent health economist who was about to turn 80. And so to have that record and that work completely pervertedit's pretty shocking. Take the example of stroke. However, he supports Obama's plans for health care reform, even though they differ from his own. But as life has gotten longer, has it gotten healthier? And I dont want any crying or wailing, but a warm gathering filled with fun reminiscences, stories of my awkwardness, and celebrations of a good life. And even more important, for most people, is the biological decline in cognitive function. CNN Sans & 2016 Cable News Network. The situation becomes of even greater concern when we confront the most dreadful of all possibilities: living with dementia and other acquired mental disabilities. Tragically all three of Young's children were born with or developed significant health issues, including cerebral palsy and epilepsy. "I have been careful to make it clear to my kids that they have to succeed --- and they have to do so on their own. Anyone who lives in Washington and has an official position viscerally understands the cost of a lack of privacy. Every year, we pick the 10 technologies that matter the most right now. Instead of predicting a cure in the foreseeable future, many are warning of a tsunami of dementiaa nearly 300 percent increase in the number of older Americans with dementia by 2050. An approach that promised to democratize design may have done the opposite. He completed his residency at Boston's Beth Israel Hospital and his oncology fellowship at the Dana-Farber Cancer Institute. Try refreshing this page and updating them one Instrumental value, such as giving priority to workers producing a vaccine, To convince me of my errors, they enumerate the myriad people I know who are over 75 and doing quite well. And many of the estimated 13 million more Americans who have survived a silent stroke suffer from more-subtle brain dysfunction such as aberrations in thought processes, mood regulation, and cognitive functioning. And the paradox, the hypocrisy, the contradiction is that many of the people who are attacking me now supported living wills and consultations with doctors about end-of-life care, before they became against it for political reasons." It is a huge loss at any age. In the early part of the 20th century, life expectancy increased as vaccines, antibiotics, and better medical care saved more children from premature death and effectively treated infections. For example, when the Agency for Health Care Policy and Research found that there was little evidence to support common back operations, orthopedic and neurosurgeons lobbied to cut funding for such research. "When Maggie approached me and introduced herself, I thought she was a patient's daughter. The recommendation is in keeping with an article Emanuel penned in 2014, arguing that the quality of life by the age of 75 had . As for the two policy implications, one relates to using life expectancy as a measure of the quality of health care. But it is inescapable as long as the parent is alive. When parents live to 75, children have had the joys of a rich relationship with their parents, but also have enough time for their own lives, out of their parents shadows. [59], Emanuel said the Complete Lives system was not meant to apply to health care in general, but only to a situation where "we don't have enough organs for everybody who needs a transplant. Going by prognosis alone might unfairly favor improving the health of a person who is healthy to begin with. That doesnt leave them much time on their ownand it is all old age. [9] He soon moved into the public sector, and held the position of Chief of the Department of Bioethics at the Clinical Center of the U.S. National Institutes of Health. They find it hard to even contemplate the idea that they are going to die and the world is going to be fine without them. In this article Emanuel questioned whether a defect in our medical ethics causes the failure of the US to enact universal health care coverage. Today he can swim, read the newspaper, needle his kids on the phone, and still live with my mother in their own house. A: In the early 1980s, we had a theory that as we live longer, were going to stay in better health. Popular zero-calorie sweetener linked to heart attack and stroke, study finds, Sleep specialist has 4 tips to help stop snoring, Is it forgetfulness or dementia? 'It robs us of our creativity and ability to contribute to work, society, the world. That is their choice, and I want to support them. Great people, maybe even people greater than you, like Newton and Shakespeare and Eulerthey died. They make it hard for grown children to become the patriarch or matriarch. Direct-to-consumer marketing by pharmaceutical companies also drives up costs. But I wont try to prolong it, either. Our in-depth reporting reveals whats going on now to prepare you for whats coming next. [20], Emanuel said the Hippocratic Oath and the codes of modern medical societies require doctors to maintain client patient confidentiality, refrain from lying to a patient, keep patients informed and obtain their consent, in order to protect the patient from manipulation and discrimination. In October 2014, Ezekiel Emanuel published an essay in the Atlantic called Why I Hope to Die at 75. Because Emanuel is a medical doctor and chair of the University of Pennsylvanias department of medical ethics and health policy, as well as a chief architect of Obamacare, the article stirred enormous controversy. Maybe this is too dismissive. I might be a little more confused, but Ill take that extra year!. Rahm Emanuel (brother) Ezekiel Emanuel (brother) Ariel Zev Emanuel (born 1961) is an American businessman and the CEO of Endeavor, an entertainment and media agency that owns the UFC. For many reasons, 75 is a pretty good age to aim to stop. He is the current Vice Provost for Global Initiatives at the University of Pennsylvania and chair of the Department of Medical Ethics and Health Policy. I qualified it in 27 different ways, saying it wasn't my view. Roomba testers feel misled after intimate images ended up on Facebook, How Rust went from a side project to the worlds most-loved programming language. Emanuel is part of a prominent family that includes brothers Ari Emanuel, a Hollywood superagent, and former Chicago Mayor Rahm Emanuel, who was Obama's first White House chief of staff. That is a fact. ', In the essay, which is published on the website with photos of his family, Emanuel says he will hold a memorial before his death to celebrate his life, but if his survivors want to have one when he has passed away it is not his 'business. I am certainly not scorning or dismissing people who want to live on despite their physical and mental limitations. From January 2009 to January 2011, he served as a. [18], At $2 trillion per year, the U.S. health-care system suffers much more from inefficiency than lack of funds. . Ummm, thats not probably a meaningful life. He said, "in the short run they require ever more money to cover the uninsured, and in the long run the unabated rise in health costs will quickly revive the problem of the uninsured." This article also noted that physician-assisted suicide has been increasingly legalized while remaining relatively rare and largely confined to oncology patients. Dr. Emanuel is the vice provost for Global Initiatives, a Diane and Robert Levy University professor, and chair of the Department of Medical Ethics and Health Policy at UPenn. There were questions about his competence since he had AIDS dementia when he signed the will. My daughters and dear friends will continue to try to convince me that I am wrong and can live a valuable life much longer. Emanuel wants to die at 75. The researchers included not just physical but also mental disabilities such as depression and dementia. And I am not advocating 75 as the official statistic of a complete, good life in order to save resources, ration health care, or address public-policy issues arising from the increases in life expectancy. My view does have important practical implications. And while children can never fully escape this weight even after a parent dies, there is much less pressure to conform to parental expectations and demands after they are gone. A: There is this view that longevity, living foreverand if not forever, 250 or 1,000 yearsis really what we ought to be aiming at. It can be destructive. Ezekiel Jonathan "Zeke" Emanuel (born September 6, 1957) is an American oncologist, bioethicist [2] and senior fellow at the Center for American Progress. Endeavor owns the Ultimate Fighting Championship, as well as Hollywood agency WME and the Miss Universe pageant, plus it has stakes in cool art fair Frieze, On Location Experiences and more.. Maybe mental functionsprocessing, memory, problem-solvingslow at 75. [59] Emanuel said that McCaughey took words out of context, omitting qualifiers such as "Without overstating it (and without fully defending it) Clearly, more needs to be done "[8][60] Emanuel once compared the word "rationing" to George Carlin's seven words you can't say on television. We are agnostics or atheists, or just dont think about whether there is a God and why she should care at all about mere mortals. This age-creativity relationship is a statistical association, the product of averages; individuals vary from this trajectory. Ezekiel Emanuel questions whether our consumption is worth our contribution in old age. He said that expensive drugs and treatments that provide only marginal benefits are the largest problems. No pacemaker and certainly no implantable defibrillator. It renders many of us, if not disabled, then faltering and declining, a state that may not be worse than death but is nonetheless deprived. What are those reasons? Registered office: 1 London Bridge Street, SE1 9GF. Were having trouble saving your preferences. Dr. Zeke Emanuel at the Klick Ideas Exchange conference in Philadelphia on June 15, 2015. She attended marches and demonstrations with her children. No heart-valve replacement or bypass surgery. [31] Sarah Palin cited the Bachmann speech and said that Emanuel's philosophy was "Orwellian" and "downright evil", and tied it to a health care reform end of life counseling provision she claimed would create a "death panel". Discover special offers, top stories, "[19], In his book The Ends of Human Life[20] Emanuel used the AIDS patient "Andrew" as an example of moral medical dilemmas. would allow patients to keep the same doctor even if they change jobs or insurance plans. Emanuel, toldABC's Dr. Richard Besser on This Week: 'I look at the data on disability, I look at the data on Alzheimer's disease, I look at the data on loss of creativity. Many people, especially those sympathetic to the American immortal, will recoil and reject my view. The connections between neurons are subject to an intense process of natural selection. Your effort and contribution in providing this feedback is much In a 2009 interview Emanuel recalled that in his childhood "worrying about ethical questions was very much part and parcel of our daily routine. 50-51. Im not going to die at 75. But everything seems sluggish. In October 2014, Ezekiel Emanuel a health policy expert, medical ethicist, and doctor who advised former President Obama wrote an infamous article in The Atlantic called "Why I Hope to Die at 75." Now, five years later, he sat down with MIT Technology Review 's Stephen Hall to discuss his stanceand why it hasn't changed. The system wastes money on administration, unnecessary tests and marginal medicines that cost a lot for little health benefit. : A rebuttal to Dr. Ezekiel Emanuels 75 age limit", "Longevity and compression of morbidity from a neuroscience perspective: Do we have a duty to die by a certain age? "I worked pretty hard and against the odds to improve end-of-life care. Writing in the October issue of The Atlantic,he says: 'There is a simple truth that many of us seem to resist: living too long is also a loss. Dr. Ezekiel Emanuel, an oncologist, adviser to Democratic presidential candidate Joe Biden and vice provost for global initiatives at the University of Pennsylvania, says Americans have a tough 12 . Ph.D. bioethicist and geriatrician, created the Medical Directive, which is described as more specific and extensive than previous living wills[22] and is a third generation Advance Directive. His daughter Rebekah, a graduate of Yale University won a George J . Read more: washingtonpost.com. But 65 will be my last colonoscopy. Ezekiel Emanuel, April 2007, Conflict of Interest in Industry-sponsored Drug Development. Dying at 75 will not be a tragedy. Are we to embrace the American immortal or my 75 and no more view? Great people, maybe even people greater than you, like Newton and Shakespeare and Eulerthey died.". Yes, with effort our children will be able to recall that great family vacation, that funny scene at Thanksgiving, that embarrassing faux pas at a wedding. [30] The article, which accused Emanuel of advocating healthcare rationing by age and disability, was quoted from on the floor of the House of Representatives by Representative Michele Bachmann of Minnesota. [20], Emanuel said that legalizing euthanasia, as was done in the Netherlands, might be counterproductive, in that it would decrease support for pain management and mental health care. Dr. Ezekiel Emanuel, UPenn Vice Provost of Global Initiatives, Former White House Health Policy Adviser, and author of 'Which Country Has the World's Best Health Care?', joined The Final Round. Moreover, even plans that reduce the number of uninsured today may find that those gains will disappear in a few years if costs continue to grow much faster than gross domestic product. Zeke, meanwhile, is the divorced father of three high-achieving daughters. And that good reason is not It will prolong your life. I will stop getting any regular preventive tests, screenings, or interventions. Activists believe. I have long argued that we should focus on giving all terminally ill people a good, compassionate deathnot euthanasia or assisted suicide for a tiny minority. Thats how long I want to live: 75 years. Also, a different patient could become equally sick in the future. Dr. Ezekiel Emanuel, a leading US oncologist and bioethicist, discusses why he will stop preventative screenings and other major medical treatments after he is 75-years-old. Levy and Robert M. Levy University Professor Professor of Health Care Management Professor of Medical Ethics and Health Policy in the Perelman School of Medicine Contact Information Primary Email: zemanuel@upenn.edu office Address: 122 College Hall Philadelphia, PA Links: CV, Personal Website Overview Research Teaching "[48], Rep. Earl Blumenauer, D-Ore., who sponsored the end-of-life provision in H.R. One leader of the event, organized by a group called Students Stand with Staff, was Gabrielle Emanuel, daughter of Zeke Emanuel, a senior adviser for health policy to the director of the. Alex, Koppelman, August 10, 2009, Ezekiel Emanuel, Obama's "Doctor Death"?. 'We are no longer remembered as vibrant and engaged but as feeble, ineffectual, even pathetic. Crimminss conclusion: There was an increase in the life expectancy with disease and a decrease in the years without disease. For me, 18 more years with which to wade through these questions is preferable to years of trying to hang on to every additional day and forget the psychic pain they bring up, while enduring the physical pain of an elongated dying process. So I want some gentle decline, but a very short amount of time. And hopefully, I will not have too many mental and physical limitations. Of course, our children wont admit it. Emanuel insists in the essay that he is not arguing for euthanasia or assisted suicide at a certain age. Ex-Biden transition COVID task force member Dr. Zeke Emanuel apologizes for suggesting unvaxxed kids are likely to contract a 'serious condition' from omicron in an interview with MSNBC. Its specificity forces us to think about the end of our lives and engage with the deepest existential questions and ponder what we want to leave our children and grandchildren, our community, our fellow Americans, the world. There are also ethical questions on how to allocate scarce resources. [13] Emanuel entered the administration with different views from President Barack Obama on how to reform health care, but was said by colleagues to be working for the White House goals. Dr. Gupta explains how this rare virus spreads, CNN gets rare inside look at NFL protocol that saved Damar Hamlin's life, Doctor explains what RSV symptoms to look for, Don't just squeeze. My Osler-inspired philosophy is this: At 75 and beyond, I will need a good reason to even visit the doctor and take any medical test or treatment, no matter how routine and painless. Ezekiel Emanuel The death of a 20-year-old woman is intuitively worse than that of a 2-month-old girl, even though the baby has had less life. more time. Lynn Sweet, The Chicago Sun-Times, August 14, 2009. What Are the Potential Cost Savings from Legalizing Physician-Assisted Suicide? "[26] Emanuel said that a historical review of opinions on euthanasia from ancient Greece to now "suggests an association between interest in legalizing euthanasia and moments when Social Darwinism and raw individualism, free markets and wealth accumulation, and limited government are celebrated."[27]. The ICU wanted guidance from Dr. Wolf as to how aggressively they should try to keep Andrew alive, as his chances of surviving a cardiac arrest were about zero. from Exeter College, Oxford in Biochemistry. Since the mid-19th century, Americans have been living longer. This Shiatsu massage pillow for back, neck, shoulder and leg pain is now reduced by more than $100 to just $54 (and shoppers say it's BETTER than a professional massage), Jim Harbaugh expects CRIMINAL CHARGES for the four Michigan State players involved in 'egregious' and 'sickening' post-game beatdown of two members of his team, Shocking new footage from Michigan-Michigan State tunnel brawl shows a Wolverines player getting SLAMMED with a helmet, Michigan neighborhood shuts down trick-or-treat Halloween festivities after vacant house is found infested with cockroaches - and health officials fear they may travel home with kids, Justice Kavanaugh says racial classifications in college admissions are 'potentially dangerous' and Justice Thomas says 'I don't know' what diversity means in tense Supreme Court argument over affirmative action, New York City businesses will now be REQUIRED to add salary ranges to job ads - with nearly a third of companies across the US now saying they are planning to INCREASE pay to deal with dissatisfied staffers, Biden hosts Halloween while bracing for a midterms nightmare and avoiding campaigns in crucial states: President hands out candy with butterflies Jill and granddaughter Naomi in the rain (but how many voters will he scare away next week?).